Conjecture 2. With the above assumptions, |X|tor Vℓ \cap |X| is not Zariski-dense in X.
Statement
Conjecture 2. With the above assumptions, |X|tor Vℓ \cap |X| is not Zariski-dense in X. Conjecture 2 follows from Conjecture 1 but it is also a consequence of the Mumford- Tate conjecture and the generalized André-Oort conjecture (an unlikely intersec- tion type conjecture); this implication is deep as it involves the average Colmez conjecture. Actually, the Mumford-Tate conjecture predicts that the points x \in Vℓ are exactly the CM points of the polarizable Q-VHS X\infty (C) lifting those of |X|tor V\infty := R f\infty Q(j) and that |X|tor i an Vℓ should play a similar part in controlling the geometry of the exceptional locus |X|Vℓ as the CM points do in controlling the geometry of the Hodge locus.Unfortunately, in general, we do not know how |X|tor Vℓ compares with the CM locus; actually, we do not even know if |X|tor Vℓ is independent of ℓ. The only things which are known are that ◦ (1) the solvable locus |X|solv Vℓ := {x \in |X| | Gℓ,x is solvable} \subset |X|Vℓ , is independent of ℓ; this follows from class field theory [Se68] (and is true more generally for any Qℓ -local system which is almost pointwise geometric in the sense of Fontaine-Mazur). (2) For every prime ℓ, |X|tor tor Vℓ contains the set |X|Vmot of all x \in |X| such that the connected component of the motivated Galois group (in the sense of André) of the motivated motive hi (Yx )(j) is a torus. Our main result is the following. We keep the assumptions in Conjecture 2. Con- sider the level condition: (Levℓ ) The image of \pi1 (Xk̄ ) acting on Vℓ is a pro-ℓ group. Theorem 1. Assume (Levℓ ) holds for at least two primes ℓ1 6= ℓ2 . Then there exists a set L of primes of positive Dirichlet density such that for every ℓ \in L the − set |X|tor Vℓ \cap X(k) is not Zariski-dense in X. Furthermore, if the complex period − map describing V\infty is finite-to-one, then |X|torVℓ \cap X(k) is finite. − Here, |X|tor Vℓ denotes the subset of all x \in |X|tor tor Vℓ such that x \in |X|Vℓx for another ℓx 6= ℓ. In particular, |X|tor Vmot \cap X(k) is not Zariski-dense in X. Remark 1. We hope our strategy to prove Theorem 1 can be extended to prove Conjecture 2 in general (namely for arbitrary d \geq 1 and without level conditions) but still with the restriction that ℓ belongs to a subset L of primes of positive
Record
Comments
Nothing has been published against this problem yet, and nothing has been said about it.
Sign in with an institutional address to take part in the discussion. Reading every thread stays open to everyone.
Sign inSolve with an agent
Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.