Conjecture 5.3 — Let hX be as above.
Statement
Let hX be as above. Then, log hX is not a Vassiliev invariant, unless it is constant. 5.3 (Co)homology of quandles Second cohomology classes of a quandle are used in order to de fine quandle cocycle invariants of knots. They are introduced as follows. Let A be an abelian group, written additively, and let C n(X; A) be the abelian group consisting of maps X n→ A, where X n denotes the direct product of n copies of X. We put C 1 Q(X; A) = C 1(X; A), C 2 Q(X; A) ={f∈ C 2(X; A)| f (x, x) = 0 for any x∈ X}, C 3 Q(X; A) ={g∈ C 3(X; A)| g(x, x, y) = 0 and g(x, y, y) = 0 for any x, y∈ X}. The coboundary operators di: C i Q(X; A)→ C i+1 Q (X; A) are given by d1f (x, y) = f (x)− f (x∗ y), d2g(x, y, z) = g(x, z)− g(x, y)− g(x∗ y, z) + g(x∗ z, y∗ z), for f∈ C 1 Q(X; A) and g∈ C 2 Q(X; A). We define the second quandle cohomol- ogy group by H 2 Q(X; A) = (kernel d2)/(image d1). It is known that H 2 Q(X; A) is isomorphic to Hom ( H Q 2 (X); A ) by the universal coefficient theorem, noting that H Q 1 (X) is free abelian (see [82]). Here, H Q 2 (X) denotes the second homol- ogy group of the dual complex of {C ⋆ Q(X; Z), d⋆}. See [82] for the definition of the nth quandle (co)homology group. Therefore, to obtain H 2 Q(X; A) for any A, it is sufficient to compute H Q 2 (X). Connected quandle X Order H Q 2 (X) H Q 3 (X) R3 3 0 Z/3Z Z[t±1]/(2, t2 + t + 1) 4 Z/2Z Z/2Z⊕ Z/4Z R5 5 0 Z/5Z Z[t±1]/(5, t− 2) 0 0 R7 0 Z/7Z Z[t±1]/(7, t− 2) 7 0 0 Z[t±1]/(7, t− 3) 0 0 Z[t±1]/(2, t3 + t + 1) 8 0 Z/2Z R9 0 Z/9Z Z[t±1]/(9, t− 2) 0 Z/3Z Z[t±1]/(3, t2 + 1) 9 Z/3Z (Z/3Z)3 Z[t±1]/(3, t2− t + 1) Z/3Z Z/3Z⊕ Z/9Z Z[t±1]/(3, t2 + t− 1) 0 0 Z[t±1]/(p, t− a) p 0for any prime p and any a̸= 0, 1∈ Z/pZ Table 5: The cohomologies of the quandles, except for the las t one, in the table are due to [264]. From a table in [264] we omit one of two dual quandles and quandles that are not connected (see remarks on Problem 5.6). The 2nd homology of Z[t±1]/(p, t− a) is due to [284]. See [264, 284] for computations of cohomolog y groups of some more quandles.
Record
- Source
- Added
Comments
Nothing has been published against this problem yet, and nothing has been said about it.
Sign in with an institutional address to take part in the discussion. Reading every thread stays open to everyone.
Sign inSolve with an agent
Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.