ProbXiv
Explorersign in
Problem archiveProblem record

Statement

Let nn be a positive integer, let F=(F1,dots,Fn)∈MDn\boldsymbol{F}=(F_1,dots,F_n)\in\mathcal M_D^n, and let Λ∈Qn\Lambda\in\mathcal Q_n. Write Λ⊗F\Lambda\otimes\boldsymbol{F} for the corresponding mixture of the marginal distributions, and let Dn(F)\mathcal D_n(\boldsymbol{F}) denote the set of distributions generated by quantile mixtures from F\boldsymbol{F}. The notation FλF^\lambda denotes the distribution obtained by scaling the quantile function of FF by λ\lambda, γ≺λ\boldsymbol\gamma\prec\boldsymbol\lambda denotes majorization, and Δn\Delta_n is the simplex of weight vectors.

Decreasing-density conjecture. For Λ∈Qn\Lambda\in\mathcal Q_n and F∈MDn\boldsymbol{F}\in\mathcal M_D^n, one has

Dn(F)⊂Dn(Λ⊗F).\mathcal D_n(\boldsymbol{F})\subset\mathcal D_n(\Lambda\otimes\boldsymbol{F}).

The following are weaker versions:

  1. For F∈MDF\in\mathcal M_D and λ,γ∈R+n\boldsymbol\lambda,\boldsymbol\gamma\in\mathbb R_+^n, if γ≺λ\boldsymbol\gamma\prec\boldsymbol\lambda, then
Dn(Fλ1,…,Fλn)⊂Dn(Fγ1,…,Fγn).\mathcal D_n(F^{\lambda_1},\dots,F^{\lambda_n})\subset\mathcal D_n(F^{\gamma_1},\dots,F^{\gamma_n}).
  1. For F1,…,Fn∈MDF_1,\dots,F_n\in\mathcal M_D,
Dn(F1,…,Fn)⊂Dn(F,…,F),\mathcal D_n(F_1,\dots,F_n)\subset\mathcal D_n(F,\dots,F),

where

F−1=1n∑i=1nFi−1.F^{-1}=\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^nF_i^{-1}.
  1. For F∈MDF\in\mathcal M_D and (λ1,…,λn)∈Δn(\lambda_1,\dots,\lambda_n)\in\Delta_n,
Dn(Fnλ1,…,Fnλn)⊂Dn(F,…,F).\mathcal D_n(F^{n\lambda_1},\dots,F^{n\lambda_n})\subset\mathcal D_n(F,\dots,F).

These questions arise because quantile-mixture classes are generally not comparable. The paper identifies decreasing densities as a natural setting inspired by the scaling theorem, but does not resolve the conjecture or its weaker forms.

Record

Comments

Nothing has been published against this problem yet, and nothing has been said about it.

Sign in with an institutional address to take part in the discussion. Reading every thread stays open to everyone.

Sign in

Solve with an agent

Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.

This opens a third-party site. Nothing is posted back to ProbXiv and nothing you write there is recorded here — what a model gives you is an attempt, which a person still has to check.