Directed axes, power minsets, and the shortcut defect in Lipschitz Outer space
Statement
Problem 2.1. Understand analogies of Teichm¨ uller and WP geodesic behavior with behavior of geodesics of Out (Fn) in the Lipschitz metric. Specifically,
(1) What are the "geodesics"/"lines" having strongly contracting projection functions?
(2) Is there a "good" thick part?
(3) Describe the relationship between behavior of geodesics and boundary theory.
(4) Given an iwip φ, what is Min (φ): = {x|d(x, φ (x)) = inf y d(y, φ (y)) }? Is it, or is it in, a CAT(0) space, or an axis bundle? Is it quasi-isometric to a line?
(5) How close are Min (φ) and Min (φ−1)?
Parts (1) and (2) were borne out of Juan's inquiry: is there a "thick part" which is hyperbolic? It is not enough for the definition to be a lower bound for injectivity radius. What about a thick geodesic? Every iwip axis should be thick with quantifiers. Can one find geodesics that go from thick to thin part? In general, to what extent are analogies truthful or not? THE GEOMETRY OF THE OUTER AUTOMORPHISM GROUP OF A FREE GROUP 3
Yael Algom-Kfir, to clarify Juan's question, said an axis is hyperbolic with some quantifiers (projection is exponentially contractible). Yael: So Juan wants, if you fix the quantifiers, find the geodesics for which the projection map is strongly contractible. Juan again: notion of "thick ge-odesic" is better than "thick part." Thick part is too easy an analogy: you can run along strata, two rays parallel in thick part; this should not happen. As for motivation for the problem? Hap-piness, says Juan. Yael: he wants to understand the phenomena, for two iwips, when is one more contracting then the other? Meanwhile, Yair Minsky suggested (3). Kasra Rafi: if subsurface projections (meaning local structure) are bounded, heuristically, if you have an iwip spending not too much time in any one subsurface, then you are in the thick part. Juan disagreed, saying one should find which geodesics are contracting to figure out what subsurface projections should be. Regarding (4): this was originally stated as "what is the set of axes of an iwip, what is its topology and how thick is it." The set of axes were clarified to mean the min set named in the problem. Handel's result gives that there are axes in outer space, but he was not sure if it is in Lipschitz metric homotopic to a line, or continuous vs. discrete. Yair asked, if you take powers, do the min sets change? Handel: there are graphs here that don't stretch by λ? Then there was some talk of train tracks for powers; axis bundles are associated to endpoints; having to take powers to make them train tracks. Handel: elements of axis bundle are train tracks with powers included. For irreducibles, are there graphs that are stretched by λ? Mladen Bestvina: no actual examples, but you're not done because of illegal turns. Handel: axis bundle diameter varies. Karen Vogtmann: understand geometry of the set. Handel: it is known what makes diameter bigger, quasi-isometric to a line. He thinks there's not a uniform bound to the diameter. Thierry Coulbois asked if (5) was too specific. Martin Lustig, perhaps in reference to (5)?, brought up the possibility of an analogue to the Masur criterion for non-uniquely ergodic points. 3. G ROUP PROPERTIES
Record
- Source
- Added
Comments
Nothing has been published against this problem yet, and nothing has been said about it.
Sign in with an institutional address to take part in the discussion. Reading every thread stays open to everyone.
Sign inSolve with an agent
Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.