ProbXiv
Explorersign in
Problem archiveProblem record

Statement

Open problem: Signings in the subtour polytope Michel Goemans Consider the subtour polytope P of the TSP on G = (V, E) (where we have dropped the degree constraints, without loss of generality, for the question below): P = {x \in RE : x(\delta(S)) \geq 2 for all S \subseteq V, x \geq 0}. But is the following true: Open question 1. For any x \in P and for any T \subseteq VPof even cardinality, does there exist a signing s : T \to {−1, +1} (with s(T ) := v\inT s(v) = 0) such that there exists a transshipment (flow) f in G with capacities {ue : e \in E} and whose excess at vertex v is s(v) for v \in T and 0 otherwise. Let f : 2V \to R+ be a nonnegative and monotone increasing submodular function with f (\varnothing) = 0. Further, assume that for each i \in V , f ({i}) = 1. If we further assume that f is integer-valued, then f is a matroid rank function. The question is whether a non-integer function f can still be well-approximated by a matroid rank? That is, does there exists a constant \alpha > 0 such that for any function f as above, there exists a matroid rank function f : 2V \to Z+ such that r(S) \leq f (S) \leq \alphar(S) \forallS \subseteq V ? \alpha Consider the subtour polytope P of the TSP on G = (V, E) (where we have dropped the degree constraints, without loss of generality, for the question below): P = {x \in RE : x(\delta(S)) \geq 2 for all S \subseteq V, x \geq 0}. For any T \subseteq V of even cardinality, we know that x/2 belongs to the dominant of the T -join polytope for G [2]. But is the following true: Open question 1. For any x \in P and for any T \subseteq VPof even cardinality, does there exist a signing s : T \to {−1, +1} (with s(T ) := v\inT s(v) = 0) such that there exists a transshipment (flow) f in G with capacities {ue : e \in E} and whose excess at vertex v is s(v) for v \in T and 0 otherwise. By Gale’s theorem (see Corollary 11.2g in [1]), this transshipment exists (s is a valid signing) if and only if s satisfies that, for all S \subset V , one has s(S) \leq x(\delta(S)) (and this can be tested efficiently and the transshipment can be found efficiently). Using splitting-off (à la Lovász), it is sufficient to consider the case in which |V | is even and T = V . The signing clearly exists if x is the incidence vector of an Hamiltonian cycle (and in this case there is an exponential number of valid signings). If x is half- integral, then a valid signing also exist

Record

Comments

Nothing has been published against this problem yet, and nothing has been said about it.

Sign in with an institutional address to take part in the discussion. Reading every thread stays open to everyone.

Sign in

Solve with an agent

Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.

This opens a third-party site. Nothing is posted back to ProbXiv and nothing you write there is recorded here — what a model gives you is an attempt, which a person still has to check.