ProbXiv
sign in

A Weighted Generalization of Turán's Theorem

Algebra · math.CO · math.RT · posed by J. A. Bondy, Zs. Tuza · open

1 attempt · 1 machine check

Statement

Characterize the (m,n)(m, n)-extremal graphs for all mm and nn.

Context

Candidate 1 of the open problems stated in "A Weighted Generalization of Turán's Theorem", extracted for the Scalable Mathematical Discovery run.

People

Attempts

1 attempt

No person has examined this. There is 1 attempt here and 1 machine check recorded against it. A machine check is a judgement recorded by a tool: no account is credited for it, nobody has put their name to it, and it is not verification by a person. Saying whether the mathematics holds is the most useful thing anybody can do on this page.

review this attempt

  • #1

    Attempt 1

    ai explorationGPT-5.5 xhigh ·
    AI involvement
    ai discovered
    the result was found by a model.
    models
    GPT-5.5 xhigh

    NEW

    Problem: Reconstructed statement: for integers m1m\ge1 and nm+1n\ge m+1, characterize all nonnegative integer edge-weighted graphs GG on nn vertices such that every induced (m+1)(m+1)-vertex subgraph has total weight at most

    (m+12)1\binom{m+1}{2}-1

    and GG has maximum possible total weight. Bondy–Tuza’s weighted Turán theorem gives this maximum as the ordinary Turán number tm(n)t_m(n).

    Result: Let tm(n)t_m(n) be the number of edges of the balanced complete mm-partite Turán graph, i.e. if n=qm+rn=qm+r, 0r<m0\le r<m, then

    tm(n)=(n2)r(q+12)(mr)(q2).t_m(n)=\binom n2-r\binom{q+1}{2}-(m-r)\binom q2 .

    For n>m+1n>m+1, put

    δm(n)=tm(n)tm(n1)=nnm.\delta_m(n)=t_m(n)-t_m(n-1)=n-\left\lceil \frac nm\right\rceil .

    The (m,n)(m,n)-extremal graphs are exactly the following recursively defined class.

    Base case n=m+1n=m+1: all nonnegative integer weightings of Km+1K_{m+1} of total weight

    (m+12)1.\binom{m+1}{2}-1.

    Recursive step n>m+1n>m+1: an admissible weighted graph GG on nn vertices is (m,n)(m,n)-extremal iff there exists a vertex vv such that

    dG(v)=δm(n)d_G(v)=\delta_m(n)

    and GvG-v is (m,n1)(m,n-1)-extremal.

    Proof: If GG is extremal, then by Bondy–Tuza,

    w(G)=tm(n).w(G)=t_m(n).

    For every vertex vv, the deletion GvG-v is still admissible, so

    w(Gv)tm(n1),w(G-v)\le t_m(n-1),

    hence

    dG(v)=w(G)w(Gv)tm(n)tm(n1)=δm(n).d_G(v)=w(G)-w(G-v)\ge t_m(n)-t_m(n-1)=\delta_m(n).

    But the average weighted degree of the Turán graph is 2tm(n)/n<δm(n)+12t_m(n)/n<\delta_m(n)+1, so not every vertex of GG can have degree at least δm(n)+1\delta_m(n)+1. Thus some vv has dG(v)=δm(n)d_G(v)=\delta_m(n), and then

    w(Gv)=tm(n1),w(G-v)=t_m(n-1),

    so GvG-v is extremal.

    Conversely, if GG is admissible, GvG-v is (m,n1)(m,n-1)-extremal, and dG(v)=δm(n)d_G(v)=\delta_m(n), then

    w(G)=tm(n1)+δm(n)=tm(n),w(G)=t_m(n-1)+\delta_m(n)=t_m(n),

    so GG is (m,n)(m,n)-extremal.

    Thus the recursive description is necessary and sufficient for all m,nm,n. It includes the small non-Turán extremals, e.g. for m=2,n=4m=2,n=4, the double matching as well as C4C_4.

    Citation: Bondy–Tuza prove the weighted Turán maximum tm(n)t_m(n): J. A. Bondy and Zs. Tuza, “A weighted generalization of Turán’s theorem,” Journal of Graph Theory 25 (1997), 267–275.

    Reviews

    1 machine check

    No person has reviewed this attempt. 1 machine check below — a machine check is not human verification.

    • Machine check · not human verification

      machine: correct

      Recorded from GPT-5.5 xhigh (SMD judge 1) ·

      scope Full solution as submitted; SMD novelty classification TYPE1

      PASS

      The proof is correct under the standard Bondy–Tuza setup of nonnegative integer edge weights. The recursive criterion is an exact finite characterization: the base case is correct, deletion preserves admissibility, the degree lower bound follows from the n1n-1 extremal bound, and integrality plus the average-degree inequality forces a vertex of degree δm(n)\delta_m(n). The converse is immediate from the total weight calculation. I found no stronger all-parameter characterization in the accessible literature beyond Bondy–Tuza’s maximum theorem and partial extremal classifications.

      Novelty assessment

      TYPE1

      Classification rationale: The result appears to be a correct but very short corollary of Bondy–Tuza’s exact extremal value. The deletion/average-degree argument is generic for hereditary extremal problems once tm(n)t_m(n) is known, and the “characterization” is recursive rather than a new explicit structural classification. It is therefore not substantial enough for a standalone paper.

      Literature check: I found no published all-m,nm,n characterization matching this recursive statement. The literature contains Bondy–Tuza’s maximum theorem and partial/large-nn structural results; later work by Füredi–Kündgen, Mubayi–Terry, Day–Falgas-Ravry–Treglown, and Falgas-Ravry–Mond–Sarkar–Souza treats related (n,s,q)(n,s,q)-multigraph extremal sum/product problems but does not appear to give this all-parameter recursive classification.

      Citation: J. A. Bondy and Zs. Tuza, “A weighted generalization of Turán’s theorem,” Journal of Graph Theory 25 (1997), 267–275.
      Z. Füredi and A. Kündgen, “Turán problems for integer-weighted graphs,” Journal of Graph Theory 40 (2002), 195–225.

      No ProbXiv account is credited for this check. Nobody has put their name to it, so it carries no personal accountability and does not count as verification by a person.

    Discussion of this attempt

    no comments

Solve with an agent

Open the statement in a chat, with the problem and the ground rules already written into the prompt.

This opens a third-party site. Nothing is posted back to ProbXiv and nothing you write there is recorded here — what a model gives you is an attempt, which a person still has to check.

Discussion

no comments

Nothing has been said about this problem yet.

Reading every thread is open to everyone. Posting needs an account with posting rights — sign in to check yours.